
Photo: Paul Blank
The FA Community Shield is never particularly something to get excited about, except for the fact that it marks the return of the English club season. This years contest proved more of the same, in the sense of the match counting as a competitive fixture, but not being played particularly seriously by either manager as the title counts for little in terms of club silverware. But one great thing about the Community Shield is that it’s the first best chance to see how a few of England’s finest are fairing before the season unfolds.
So as Manchester United always looked the better and won after 0-0 in regular time through 3-1 on penalties, let’s analyze the defending Premiership and Champions League title holders first. The first thing that comes to mind is that Manchester United always look to be missing a spark in attack when missing either Ronaldo, or Rooney. But when missing both, the offensive contingent looks especially lethargic, with Giggs and Tevez poor substitutes in terms of attacking prowess these days. Although Tevez won man of the match, and deservedly so, United never looked fit to score against Portsmouth.
The return of Gary Neville should have been more glorious, and may have been, if not for the fact that the defense looked ten times more capable after the skipper was substituted with Wes Brown in the 65th minute. Showing that despite Neville’s former glory, the championship combo should remain Brown, Vidic, Ferdinand and Evra.
Nani showed himself as having all the talent in the world, but still lacking the ability to be a successful part of Manchester United. The big issue this time proving to be his failure to understand United’s attacking flow. Nani frequently slowed play to a crawl during attack, to instead of look for a pass do a few step-overs and then attempt a pass or a cross after the key opportunity, leading to confusion from the rest of the team. And who can forget the Portuguese International’s penchant for grabbing the ground any time a defender looks to be getting the better of him, apparently his rookie season in the Premiership hasn’t taught him any better on the eve of his second trip round the tournament.
Other than that though, given the fact that Rooney and Ronaldo will be back soon, Rooney could be back as soon as next week for United’s first fixture, Manchester United look well more than ready. Pompey on the other hand. . .not so much.

Lackluster defense doesn’t begin to describe the Portsmouth back four. Campbell was the only contingent that perhaps had a redeemable performance, but Distin, Johnson and Hreidarsson were absolutely dreadful. With a big emphasis on Distin who always looked entirely incompetent at any attempt to defend intelligently against the rolling United attack.
Although David James can look forward to holding England’s top spot, as his performance was exceptional. As the 0-0 score sheet would tell, both goalkeepers had a good day, but James had to work by far much harder to keep his net empty for the ninety minutes. Especially against Tevez, who had the best attempt on a pass from Carrick which David James only just saved on his finger tips at full stretch across his goal-line.
But the real story here, is that Pompey need to spend some money on a mid-fielder. Because Crouch and Defoe were nonexistent for most of the match. Nobody was available to feed Crouch the ball, and that’s a huge problem for Redknapp’s newly acquired scoring machine. As Crouch can’t net the ball, if you can’t get him the ball. With Defoe being too selfish to ever look to the big man if the Englishman thinks he has a sniff of a chance, Pompey seriously need to solve the situation before next week.
Although the club likely doesn’t have the money for someone of proper skill, it goes to show you so far that Portsmouth have a way to go to compete with England’s top clubs. But if Redknapp can refocus his defense, and scrap together a few pounds to buy a star mid, Pompey may have a team. Because the scoring contingent of Defoe and Crouch is a perfect match, if only they had a capable crosser coming down the left or right side of the pitch.
